Originally aired March 3, 1999
Detective Andy Trudeau (T.W. King) has been called to the office of the coroner (Kopell) to identify the body of "Jane Doe".
To Andy's horror, it's somebody he knows: Prue Halliwell (Shannen Doherty). But a mystery is just around the "coroner" (sorry, couldn't resist!).
After going to break the tragic news to Prue's sisters--and finding Prue there, alive and well--he speaks with the coroner again.
The coroner assures him that he got Prue's records from the DMV, and the fingerprints matched those of the body, down to the last whorl.
Andy knows there's something strange going on. He tells the coroner not to mention this case to anybody.
Andy abruptly walks out, leaving the coroner perplexed at his unorthodox request....